Who bears the risk when land use changes?
In February 2016, Léandre Ruberintwari began renting a house from Issa Seleman Habimana and Amina Tuginama. By November 2016, the arrangement had turned into a sale, the parties executed a land transfer agreement before a land notary for a parcel of land registered as UPI 1/02/10/01/217, and Ruberintwari paid RWF 75,000,000 (Approx USD 52,000) for it. At the time, the land registry listed the parcel for residential use through 2031, and the land notary certified that the transaction met all legal requirements. Ruberintwari took possession, moved in tenants, and used the property without incident.
The trouble began when Ruberintwari applied to have the title formally transferred into his name. The land registration authority refused the transfer, informing him that the parcel in fact sat within a state-owned wetland, on which private title could not be registered. Ruberintwari sued Habimana and Tuginama before the Intermediate Court of Ngoma, seeking to have the sale contract nullified for fraud and to recover the purchase price. He argued the sellers must have known the land was in a wetland and sold it to him anyway. The Intermediate Court dismissed his claim, and Ruberintwari appealed to the High Court's Rwamagana Chamber.
The High Court sided with Ruberintwari. It reversed the Intermediate Court's judgment in full, nullified the sale contract, and ordered Habimana and Tuginama to refund the RWF 75,000,000 purchase price plus lawyer's fees and costs. Habimana and Tuginama then appealed to the Court of Appeal, which is the decision discussed here.
The parties' arguments
Habimana and Tuginama, raised two lines of argument. First, they renewed an objection they had already lost twice, that the Intermediate Court of Ngoma had no jurisdiction to hear the case at all, since the land lay in Gasabo District and the sale had been executed there, so the case belonged before the Intermediate Court of Gasabo instead. Second, on the merits, they argued that they had sold land for which they held valid ownership documents dating from 2011, that the land notary's own search of the land registry at the time of sale confirmed residential status, and that the official record classifying the parcel as wetland was not issued until late 2019, three years after the sale. On that basis, they denied any fraud and argued the High Court had wrongly nullified a contract that was valid when made.
Ruberintwari, answered that the jurisdiction objection missed the point, he had not sued to recover the land itself, which would indeed belong before the court where the land is situated, but to have the sale contract declared void, a claim that under Rwandan procedural law belongs before the court where the defendant resides. On the merits, he maintained that Habimana and Tuginama must have known, or should have known, that the parcel had been reclassified as wetland, since local authorities had reportedly been informing residents since 2014 that wetlands belonged to the state, and that selling him land they knew to be compromised amounted to fraud entitling him to rescind the sale and recover his money, together with damages for the rental income he lost when the house was later demolished.
The legal questions
The Court of Appeal framed two questions from these competing positions. The first was procedural, where a claim seeks to nullify a land sale contract rather than to recover the land itself, is jurisdiction determined by where the defendant resides, or by where the land is located? The second went to the merits, does a government's later reclassification of land use, here from residential to protected wetland, retroactively invalidate a sale contract or expose the seller to liability for fraud, where the seller held valid title and no adverse zoning record existed at the time of sale?
The Court of Appeal's decision
On jurisdiction, the Court of Appeal agreed with Ruberintwari. Under Rwanda's law on the jurisdiction of courts, cases concerning immovable property must be filed where that property is located, but that rule applies only where the property itself is the object of the claim. Since Ruberintwari's claim sought the nullification of a contract, not the recovery of the land, the applicable rule was the general one, jurisdiction lies with the court of the place where the defendant resides. Because Habimana and Tuginama lived within the territorial jurisdiction of the Intermediate Court of Ngoma, that court had properly heard the case, and the renewed jurisdiction objection failed for a third time.
On the merits, the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court's decision and reinstated the contract. It held that the sale met every requirement of a valid contract under Rwandan contract law, mutual consent, capacity, a lawful object, and a lawful cause, all confirmed before a land notary who was satisfied the transaction complied with land law.
Drawing on the distinction, recognised in French civil law scholarship, between fraud committed when a contract is formed and fraud committed in how it is later performed, the Court of Appeal examined both. As to formation, it found nothing to show that Habimana and Tuginama knew, in November 2016, that the parcel had been or would be reclassified as wetland, the official land-authority record establishing the wetland status was issued only in November 2019, three years later, and Ruberintwari himself admitted under questioning that he did not know the land was wetland when he bought it, undermining his claim that the sellers alone possessed that knowledge.
As to performance, the Court of Appeal found that the failure to complete the title transfer was not caused by anything Habimana and Tuginama did or omitted to do, but by an intervening decision of public authority, a cause external to both parties that excuses non-performance under ordinary contract principles unless a party has expressly guaranteed against it, which neither seller had done here.
Because no fraud was shown at either stage, the Court of Appeal found no basis to nullify the sale or to order repayment of the purchase price, and it struck out the High Court's award of RWF 75,000,000 (Approx USD 52,000), together with the associated lawyer's fees and costs.
The Court of Appeal also rejected Ruberintwari's cross-appeal for further damages, including lost rental income and compensation tied to the demolition of the house, since he had likewise failed to prove that Habimana and Tuginama bore any responsibility for the parcel's reclassification or for the blocked transfer.
Finding that each side had partly prevailed and partly lost across the various proceedings, the Court of Appeal declined to award legal fees or procedural costs to either party.
What it means for you
For buyers, the ruling is a caution against relying on registration records alone. A seller's valid title at the time of sale will not later be undone by a change in official land use, and a buyer who wants protection against that risk needs to negotiate it into the contract rather than assume the law will supply it after the fact. Prudent buyers should independently investigate municipal zoning plans, wetland and environmental buffer designations, and long-term land-use projections before committing to a purchase, rather than relying solely on historical registry entries.
For sellers, the decision confirms that holding clean, verifiable title at the time of sale is generally a complete defence to a fraud claim, even if the land is reclassified soon afterward. Liability turns on what the seller knew and represented at the moment of contracting, not on what a government agency later decides.
For both sides, the case is also a reminder that Rwandan courts treat unforeseen acts of public authority as an external cause that excuses non-performance of a contract, rather than as a breach by either contracting party. Anyone negotiating a real estate sale who wants a different allocation of that risk, for instance a seller-funded refund if a title transfer is later blocked by a zoning change, needs to say so explicitly in the contract, since the default legal position will otherwise place that risk on the buyer.