Not every procurement dispute in Rwanda can go to arbitration

Not every procurement dispute in Rwanda can go to arbitration

Most contracts with public bodies in Rwanda contain an arbitration clause. Many suppliers read that clause and assume that any disagreement with the Government will end before an arbitral tribunal in Kigali. That assumption is wrong in at least three situations, and a recent court decision shows how much can be at stake.

The laws involved

Public purchasing is governed by Law n° 031/2022 of November 21, 2022 governing public procurement, together with Ministerial Order n° 001/23/10/TC of October 10, 2023 establishing regulations governing public procurement.

Arbitration is governed by Law n° 005/2008 of February 14, 2008 on arbitration and conciliation in commercial matters. The country’s arbitration institution was created by Law n° 51/2010 establishing the Kigali International Arbitration Centre and determining its organisation, functioning and competence, published in the Official Gazette on February 28, 2011.

First limit. Disputes before the contract is signed

An arbitration clause is part of a contract. A bidder who loses a tender has no contract with the procuring entity, so it has no arbitration clause to rely on.

A complaint about the tender documents, the evaluation of bids or the award follows the review procedure in the procurement law. The bidder first raises the matter with the procuring entity. If the answer is unsatisfactory, the bidder may take the complaint to the Independent Review Panel. A party that is still dissatisfied may go to court.

The detailed steps are in Articles 173 to 180 of the Ministerial Order. They cover the review period before the procuring entity, the appeal to the Independent Review Panel and the appeal fee, the contents and admissibility of the appeal, and notification of the panel’s decision.

The time limits in this procedure are short and are counted in days. A bidder who spends those days drafting a notice of arbitration will find the door closed. The same is true of debarment. A decision by the Rwanda Public Procurement Authority to exclude a company from public tenders is an administrative act with its own procedure. It is not a contract claim.

Second limit. What the contract actually says

Once a contract is signed, disputes about performance, payment, delay and termination are contractual. They can be referred to arbitration if the contract provides for it.

The clause must be read with care. Public contracts often require the parties to attempt an amicable settlement first, sometimes for a fixed number of days. Starting arbitration before that step is completed invites an objection. A supplier should know which applies before the first invoice is sent.

Third limit. When a criminal case is pending

This is the limit that catches experienced parties off guard.

Rwandan procedure contains a rule, found in Article 115 of Law n° 027/2019 of September 19, 2019 relating to criminal procedure, under which a civil decision must wait when a related criminal case is pending. The courts treat it as a rule of public order. Parties cannot waive it.

On April 12, 2024, the High Commercial Court applied that rule to an arbitral award in Kalpataru Power Transmission v. Rwanda Energy Group, case RCOMA 00049/2021/HCC. The dispute came out of a contract with a public utility. The arbitral tribunal had issued its award on September 20, 2021 and had found no proof of fraud or corruption. A related criminal case was pending at the time. The court held that the tribunal should have waited, and it set the award aside.

Under Article 47 of the arbitration law, a court may set aside an award on limited grounds, and conflict with public policy is one of them. The Supreme Court had considered the same rule on October 21, 2016 in Soras Assurances Generales Ltd v. Tromea Ltd, case RCOMAA 0020/16/CS. In that case it refused to set aside the award and held that the rule does not automatically apply to every civil matter. The 2024 decision shows that lower courts read those limits flexibly.

The lesson for suppliers is this. Allegations of corruption are not unusual in public contracts. If a criminal investigation touches the same facts, an arbitration that carries on may produce an award that cannot be enforced. Years of work and cost can go down the drain.

What suppliers should do

At the tender stage, keep a calendar of the review deadlines from the day the award is announced.

Before signing, read the dispute clause. Check whether it provides for amicable settlement, arbitration or the courts, and where the arbitration is seated. Ask for changes during negotiation if the clause is unclear. After signature, the supplier’s hands are tied.

When a dispute arises, follow each step in the clause and keep proof that it was followed.

If a criminal complaint or investigation relates to the contract, raise it with the tribunal at once. Ask whether the arbitration should be stayed.

In a nutshell

Arbitration remains a sound choice for contract disputes with public bodies in Rwanda, and the Kigali International Arbitration Centre gives parties a local forum. It is not a route for every dispute. Complaints about the tender go to the review procedure. Contract claims go where the contract sends them. And where a criminal case is in play, the arbitration may have to wait.